Menu of Lucy's New York Style Pizza in Wendell, Idaho, USA

Menu Overview

Lucy's New York Style Pizza, nestled in the humble setting of a truck stop in Wendell, Idaho, offers an intriguing blend of classic New York-style pizza and inventive menu items that pleasantly surprise. The 15" pizza selection stands out, especially the Supreme with its vibrant mix of pepperoni, peppers, onions, black olives, and mushrooms—an authentic, hearty slice of New York’s famed thin crust tradition. For those seeking bold flavors, the Game Changer pizza is a must-try. Its honey garlic sauce, combined with pepperoni, bacon, and blue cheese crumbles, delivers a complex, unforgettable flavor profile that justifies its name.

Beyond pizzas, Lucy’s menu showcases a range of well-crafted calzones. The Meaty Small Calzone impresses with its generous filling of pepperoni, ham, sausage, meatball, and bacon, perfect for a protein-packed bite. Vegetarian diners aren’t left out, with the Veggie Calzone boasting fresh artichokes, peppers, onions, olives, and mushrooms, delivering balance and satisfying depth. The inclusion of subs like the Pepperoni Melt Sub and Meatball Sub rounds out the menu, offering wholesome comfort food options.

What truly elevates Lucy’s New York Style Pizza is their commitment to flavor authenticity amidst a casual, truck stop environment. The dough holds a respectable balance—thin yet chewy, though some dishes like the fried mozzarella highlight opportunities for refinement in texture and melting technique. Service, while occasionally slow, is marked by friendliness and warmth from staff like Emmie, Morgan, and Jennifer, who contribute to a welcoming atmosphere despite the unconventional setting.

Additionally, the restaurant shines with unexpected specialties like the Gluten-Free Zestpian Pizza, praised for its perfect heat level from jalapeños and a harmonious mix of pineapple and herbed chicken that elevates the gluten-free experience. The Loaded Baked Potato Pizza, featuring potatoes, bacon, sour cream, and scallions, provides a creative twist that is both comforting and innovative.

Though located within a truck stop, the ambience is surprisingly charming, with décor that adds character and a drink menu packed with playful options, including standout huckleberry milkshakes. Lucy’s New York Style Pizza is not just a stopover; it’s a local discovery of solid, flavorful pizzas and sandwiches made with care, perfect for anyone craving authentic tastes without a frills façade.

In summary, Lucy’s offers a genuine taste of New York’s pizza culture with a creative edge, approachable pricing, and menu diversity. While a few elements like melt consistency and service speed could use polish, the overall experience hits the mark for comfort food lovers seeking quality and variety in an unexpected place.